Initiation into Meditation
by Alphonse and Rachel Goettmann
Translated by Theodore and Rebecca Nottingham
tednottingham@hotmail.com
Translated
from the original French:
L'Au Dela
au Fond de nous-mêmes
Copyright
1998
TABLE
OF CONTENTS
Preface
Introduction
I.
WHICH PATH FOR US?
In
despair on the edge of the cliff
The
True Dimension of Humanity
Meditation:
A Privileged Path
II.
ON THE WAY TOWARD THE WAY: HOW TO MEDITATE
Sitting
in meditation
The
Sensation of the Divine
Meditating
in the Breath of God
III.
THE TRUE JOY
Asceticism:
beacon on the way
If
I have not love, I am nothing
You
are the light of the world
Appendix
I SOME EXERCISES TO FACILITATE PROPER BREATHING
Appendix
II SUMMARY OF THE ENTRY INTO THE FUNDAMENTAL POSTURE
PREFACE
by
Theodore J. Nottingham
Out
in the rolling hills of eastern France, on the edge of the German
border, in a land called Alsace-Lorraine, there is a very special
community known as Bethanie. It is a place of great religious activity
destined to renew Christian spirituality in our day. Across Europe,
seekers of the light are finding new access to the living Christ
through the work of this community. Books, journals, sessions aimed
at deepening our experience of the Presence of God are all part
of Bethanie's mission. Hundreds have journeyed to this little out
of the way place deep in the French countryside, some twenty minutes
from the ancient city of Metz.
Situated
on a spot of land which once housed a monastery in the seventh century,
Bethanie is known as a Center of Hesychast Meditation, Bible and
Tradition. Its directors are Alphonse and Rachel Goettmann. He is
a priest in the Orthodox Church of France, a relatively recent development
in the Body of Christ which seeks to return to the earliest Traditions
of the Faith. Alphonse and Rachel are themselves living examples
of Bethanie's mission--the transformation of human beings into children
of God, channels of the Divine Love, new creations in Christ. Alphonse
and Rachel are lovers of God, people who radiate a rare joy, humility,
and unconditional affection.
They
have lived a lifetime aimed at becoming receptive to the Spirit
and transparent to its expression in the world. For years they were
students and close friends of Karlfried Graf Durckheim, the renowned
spiritual teacher and psychotherapist who has helped untold thousands
find the Christ within. Durckheim died in December of 1988, at the
age of 91, and the Goettmanns carry on his teachings while ushering
them into new dimensions through their experience of the Orthodox
liturgy and the wisdom of the early saints of the Church.
Here
in this quiet setting men and women learn to discover the Prayer
of the Heart, that opening to the Spirit which makes possible encounters
too deep for words and transforms daily life into a sacramental
event. Here people become empowered to go out into the world as
instruments and messengers of Unconditional Love. For the Goettmanns,
it is clear that the men and women who come to drink at their wells
are looking for something more than inner peace and serenity. They
are looking for the Christ, the Holy One of God who has put a human
face on the unknowable "I Am." There is a great hunger worldwide
for spiritual awakening and Bethanie is on the cutting edge of these
new horizons so vital to the future of Humanity.
To that
end, the Goettmanns have published several books which are now being
translated for the English-speaking world: Prayer of Jesus --
Prayer of the Heart (published by Paulist Press in the fall
of 1990, then republished by Inner Life Publication in 1996), Dialogue
on the Path of Initiation: An introduction to the thought of Karlfried
Graf Durckheim (published by Globe Press Books in the spring
of 1992), and The Spiritual Wisdom and Practices of Early Christianity
(Inner Life Publications, 1994).
The
following quote from this volume offers a hint of their work and
insight: "Only this complete opening to the amazing Love of God
makes it possible for us to become ourselves, for we have been created
to respond to this call. From it is born all fruitfulness. Transparent
to God, we recognize God everywhere and in everything; we now become
truly sensitive to another in his or her full reality, capable of
communicating beyond impersonal appearances. Previously we could
know nothing of God's purpose for the world, but now our knowing
receives its light from the Love lived in the depths of our prayer.
Through our inner experience, we know that God maintains the world
by the power of this Love, and wants to carry it through this Love
to its fulfillment, its divinization."
During
our walk around the community, Rachel rang the old church bell which
echoed across the peaceful countryside. The ringing was not done
to announce the top of the hour or the time of worship, but to call
everyone within earshot to a remembrance of the living God. As the
first colors of sunset spread across the autumn sky, we had to ready
ourselves for the three hour train ride back to Paris. It was painful
to leave this place whose very atmosphere seemed to sparkle with
the glory of God. So much worship and so much love had transfigured
a plot of land into sacred space. In that little community, made
up of a few families committed to growing together in their common
faith and sharing it with all who are on such a pilgrimage, we found
a people of God bearing witness to the nearness and nurturing love
of our Creator. Only that kind of daily profound transformation
which makes us transparent to the Divine Love, or Being as Durckheim
called it, can become a beacon for its age and all those to come.
Bethanie
echoes today with the magnificent harmonies of the ancient Orthodox
liturgy and the deep consciousness of lives focused on the present
moment and the Presence of the Holy within in. It is a blessed place,
an incubator for the regeneration of the Christian life. Its leaders
are humbly living in that timeless encounter with our Creator, the
experience of which is the hope of humanity.
INTRODUCTION
by
Alphonse and Rachel Goettmann
This
is not a book, but the utterance of a continual search verified
through experience. These are the words of a life. More than thirty
years ago, the decisive call came and there was no turning back:"Deep
within, you are someone entirely different..." It was an explosion!
But the Way still had to be found. The stages succeeded one another,
but always and obstinately in the same direction: contemplative
Silence. Here alone are we placed before the power of the call and
the depths of its promises. We human beings are an abyss of dazzling
mystery who come to self-realization only in and through contemplation,
and no action can replace it.
A person's
entire being and behavior depend directly and completely on this
beyond within... Such a conviction came through the most personal
experiences, in solitude and in the desert. It was unique. And the
more it became unique, the more it opened upon the universal. Our
Love, that great Silent One beyond all words of love, first showed
it to us; beginning with our wedding, it has penetrated step by
step toward a sharing in meditation which has never ceased. This
has become our daily bread. Now we share it with hundreds of people
who come from all spiritual, cultural, and geographic horizons searching
for the Essential. Bethanie, Center of Hesychast Meditation, Bible
and Tradition located near Metz in eastern France, is the fruit
of this experience.
But
if we can share today the harvest of our discoveries, it is because
there was a sower: Karlfried Graf Durckheim. We have described elsewhere
the adventure of our encounter with this Master and the richness
of his message (Dialogue on the Path of Initiation). As a
true Master, Graf Durckheim, far from imposing his law upon us,
has opened us to our own creativity. We attempt here to enter into
the understanding and experience of meditation as we practiced it
with Durckheim for many years, seeking to break through the Mystery
which inhabits it and calls to us as disciples of Christ. And the
more we break through, the more we rejoign the living waters of
Holy Scripture and the grand tradition of our Fathers!
Meditation
is not only the activity of distant Asians, but the lever of all
wisdom. The Orient calls the West to this forgotten reality. Oriental
wisdom can greatly enrich us in this contemplative path, on the
condition that we open ourselves to it with prudence and discernment,
as did the Fathers of the Church who, in their day, knew how to
make use of the best insights of Greek philosophy. They understood
that all truth, wherever it appears, is a manifestation of the Word
of God... This initiation into meditation is actually an initiation
into humanity. It is an invitation to the Joy at the heart of a
world without hope, and a call for people to rediscover their true
humanity!
I
WHICH
PATH FOR US?
IN
DESPAIR ON THE EDGE OF THE CLIFF
Adam,
where are you? On the summits of your intellect or in the depths
of your being? This question is addressed to all people of all times,
and to each one of us in particular. We often look back painfully
on our past or peer avidly into the future, but we always flee our
today, our present moment, the only certainty of our existence.
To understand what is going on, we must be aware of the fact that,
from the beginning of our century, more things have happened than
in the past six thousand years of written history.
We are
born into a crack of time and our problems are unlike those of any
previous generation. According to sociologists, there is no doubt
about the absolutely exceptional phase in which humanity finds itself.
Extraordinary promises stretch out before us. The scientific and
technical revolution of the twentieth century could be the greatest
opportunity humanity has ever had to fulfill itself. For the first
time in history, we have the means of mastering our destiny. Everything
points to the possibility that the stage which is to be undertaken
now is as important as the first step which led humans to create
tools. However, everything will depend on a radical choice. Alongside
the exceptional promises are threats which are just as great. A
dramatic struggle is underway between ourselves and our genius.
It is up to us, with the exception of a stupid accident which is
always possible, as to whether this struggle ends in the most miserable
failure or opens out onto a new stage of our development. The burning
question is this: will we reach a point of no return and what must
we do to avoid this catastrophe?
The
scientific revolution, which has become a technical one, is out
of control. First oriented toward the natural world, it now surrounds
us, envelops us, and has suddenly penetrated into the depths of
our hearts through the flood of mass media, finally reaching into
our very genes with the power to transform us biologically. For
the first time, we are in a phase of history where our progress
threatens our existence. What now? Disintegration? New beginning?
Metamorphosis? Adam, where are you?...In despair! We are cut off
from our secret intimacy with the cosmos. Little by little, we have
transformed our planet into an immense factory which exploits matter
and energy. Pushed on by a blind and disordered instinct, we condemn
it to pillage, poisoning, and ruin. Never before have we so assaulted
our environment. Nature is dying, boxed into national parks where
our descendants will come and see what forests once looked like.
Thousands of species have already disappeared. The reality which
was the condition of humanity for centuries is now collapsing. Will
we be able to survive all alone?
Cut
off from the cosmos, we now evolve in an apocalyptic universe: how
many have already fallen beneath the mushroom cloud and how many
more fall at this very moment beneath the concentrations of radioactive
dust creating all sorts of infirmities and cancers? The food chain
is polluted, mutations in germinal cells are probable. Having become
a stumbling robot, we are going insane and, to protect ourselves,
we are arming ourselves in a demented way. This is plunging us into
the cruelty of wars, a universe of genocide and aggression where,
as Helder Camara says, is dropped the most catastrophic of all bombs:
the M bomb, the explosion of misery! Technical civilization exerts
on us many pressures from earliest childhood and, in the weakest
among us, creates psychopaths, drug addicts, and even criminals.
Humanity is crushed by the products it has fabricated.
Machines
are part of our biological life like the shell of a snail, but we
are snails who are being crushed by our shells while still creating
them. The condition of our existence then becomes pathological.
Exposed, uprooted, and without refuge, we fall into a chaotic multiplication
of needs, a neurosis for material comfort and an impossibility of
living without mass communication, especially television. This is
an imbalance of Nature, and for some, an irreversible current. Beneath
the overdevelopment of human power with its increase of abundance
and leisure lies an incredible emotional, psychological and moral
underdevelopment. The effort toward a scientific society has not
worked. We are giving up on the illusion that science holds the
key to all our problems. Not only do we no longer dominate our environment,
but we have lost the lever of our inner universe.
The
mechanical organization of existence has reduced everything to servitude
and destroyed that which cannot fit into its structures. It begets
a common sinking into the superficial and the indifferent. And we
are now becoming aware of the irreparable loss of substance which
has taken place. The issue is not the condemnation of technology
or science, but to point out that, without consciousness, they are
blind and drunken and destroy humanity. We are losing ourselves
in what should be a means rather than an end. The era of the computer
can only lead to a new age of civilization if we rediscover and
hold tightly to our true aims. Technical advance yes, but by whom
and for what? It is our identity which is the issue, the interpretation
of a certain image we have of ourselves which is the source of all
our ills. The best observers seem to agree today on this point:
the underdevelopment of humanity, the deficiency of our being, and
our inner misery are the common denominator of all our various underdevelopments:
psychological, physiological and material. It is in our very being
that we are sick!
Let
us not fall once more into new hypotheses which might make us feel
better. Humanity is amputated from its essential interiority, its
deep roots, and the mystery of its vital center. For those who know
how to see, there is visible, beneath our masks and appearances,
the diseases of the soul and the spirit. What must we do? From everywhere,
we are projected to the surface, pulverized and reduced to mechanics.
The snail is crushed by its shell, yet continues to create it...
From the moment we value human beings by their capacity to produce,
the individual loses his or her uniqueness. We then cease to be
ourselves and fall into the functional. Here we are objectified,
torn from the depths which make us truly human, transparent to our
being and opened to the inner source from which we can continually
receive ourselves. For the world, to be is to be adapted to objectivity,
accepting to reduce our mysterious and immense consciousness, and
to function only in the collective and the general.
We have
abandoned our heart to be dominated by our mind. Reason without
the heart is unreasonable! Can we have a tree without its roots?
The House of humanity is divided, and we live only in the attic.
The vast resources of being remain unused and are drying up in a
spiritual void. The rationalization of daily life on all levels
continually bludgeons Life in its very essence, and we exist in
the restricted spaces of abstraction and superficial conduct. What
is the point of furnishing my attic if the roof keeps me from standing
up? We have identified ourselves with our rational self and let
the most important part of ourselves fall into the night of the
subconscious. Each one of us can notice that, as we age, we leave
behind that original wholeness which radiates from the little child
and we become increasingly strangers to ourselves. Except for certain
privileged hours of our life, it is very rare that we correspond
with who we are in our depths, present to ourselves and our surrounding,
that we reach our true capacities, that we become authentic. We
always remain outside of our own reality.
Most
of the time, the experience we have of ourselves does not include
who we really are. In the same way, there is an abyss between the
experience we have of our environment and what that environment
actually is. The thing itself, as Kant said, remains a stranger
to us, closed in on itself; we only see appearances. This is where
many of our conflicts and confusions come from. Little by little
we are led to decomposition, dragging with us the rotting of an
entire civilization and the crumbling of religion. The reduction
of humanity to its rational and objectifying "self," exclusively
functional and utilitarian, has introduced a great schysm within
us. The unity of being is broken and the consciousness of belonging
to an undivided All, the openness toward the beyond within us, where
we are originated and receive ourselves, is lost. Our anchoring
is no longer in the Absolute.
Divided
within and consequently separated from the rest of the universe
of which we were in a way the summary, cut off from the Source of
life, we have turned toward our "little self" living on the surface
of things. And the unlimited field of our mystery becomes a tiny
prison in which, alone, we end up adoring ourselves! Uncentered
from God, concentrated on ourselves, we make ourselves the ultimate
purpose of life. The spirit cut off from God and no longer nourished
by Him, feeds on the soul. But finding only emptiness there where
God communicated the fullness of life, the soul in turn cannibalizes
the body and seeks the pleasures of the flesh. The body itself,
now a desecrated Temple and no longer dwelling in the Holy of Holies,
is literally thrown out, extraverted through its pores and its five
senses, and delivered to avarice and possessiveness.
Everything
is done through the deformed and deforming prism of this disintegrated
autonomy, the objectifying and rational consciousness. It only sees
by ascertaining, that is, by fixing in a static state all living
reality, projecting it out of its mystery toward the dead abstraction
of concept, reducing it to a useful object. The reaction is always
immediate: as soon as our senses come in contact with something,
they classify it, define it, tag it: "doctor"..."laborer"..."peasant"..."flower"...
"plane"... "good"..."bad"..."cold"..."hot"... We see only the superficial.
It is a horizontal view in which everything is separated, opposed,
broken. The inner sight, rooted in the luminous depths of Being,
uncovers not only the appearances, the visible form, but "that which
informs the form," and reveals how "all is in each thing and each
thing is in all," as a wave is the concentration of the entire ocean.
This is true seeing. Our ordinary consciousness is isolated, windowless,
veils everything through the mental screen, knows only itself and
filters all reality, which is so stupendous in its invisible dimension.
From
the days of the prophets, such persons have been recognized for
their "lack of depth" and their "lack of roots" to the extent that
they "see without seeing, hear without hearing, for their heart
(their inner center) is hardened" (Mtt 13). In other words, all
relationships are falsified: with oneself, with others, with the
world, with God. This is perversion in the truest sense: "spirit-soul-body"
becomes "body-soul-spirit"...Not only is their direction inversed,
but their unity is lost. This is the disposition which treats the
self as absolute, as an end in itself, and therefore uses everything
to satisfy it and augment its power. This is not simply a bad temperament,
but the fundamental inauthenticity of a divided consciousness with
no direction in the midst of arbitrary impulses, given over to brokenness
and error, a self capable of inventing the hydrogen bomb and concentration
camps for whoever does not kneel before it...
The
more this affirmation of the self increases in power, and that is
its tendency in each moment, the more it falls into division, dualism,
rupture: I separate myself from others. But this inflation of self
depends on others, on their manipulation. This is a complete change
of perspective, an inner alienation which is called original sin,
not only because it was committed at the dawn of some distant past,
but because I commit it every day and it cuts me off from my deeper
identity, there where I originate, and because of this, all my efforts,
even the most insignificant, are aborted from the place of their
birth. The person who has lost his or her identity is like the stream
that has lost its source: the stream becomes a pond for ducks, muddy
and stagnating.
It has
ceased to be a stream and lost its joy whose nature is to receive
the surging life of the source. It is still water, but for how long?
Amputation...Exile...Wandering far from our vitalizing Source...The
mundane self never ceases to be seduced by the fruits of the Tree
of Knowledge, that is, by self-idolatry. We want to become gods
through our own efforts and not through the Tree of Life which is
God. It is the story of the stream and its source, humanity's supreme
attempt against all Covenant with anything other than itself. This
has nothing to do with the legends of certain catechisms or the
moral of bad sermons. "To sin," in one of its etymological meanings,
means to miss the mark, to have the wrong aim, and therefore to
miss the goal.
Persons
who are cut off from their roots in the divine, from the beyond
within, live only in the reduced dimensions of time and space (the
horizontal dimension) with the reduced consciousness of the "little
self." They have ceased to be persons and are now merely individuals.
They have lost their essential dimension, beyond time and space,
the one which constitutes them as persons. Can such people ever
find happiness?
Meister
Eckhart has left us a picture, which defies all logic, of the inexpressible
happiness which rises in persons who recover their true identity:
"God takes such pleasure in this similitude or identity, that
he pours out his nature and his whole being. His pleasure is as
great as a horse let loose in a flat plain that gallops as fast
as he can because that is his nature and pleasure. So it is with
God. It is his pleasure and rapture to discover someone's true identity
because he can place his whole nature in it, being himself this
identity."
We have
said that humanity is sick in its very being. This despair is collective
only because it is within each one of us.
At the
same time, we continue to seek to remedy our distress on the external
level. Cut off from our source, we find ourselves before a void
from which rise three great sufferings, the three fundamental distresses
of human beings, the immediate consequences of our inner rupture,
and the common denominator of all our ills:
• the
fear of death,
• the
meaninglessness of life,
• solitude.
First
of all, this enormous security in which we envelop ourselves, from
the house with its many gadgets to the most sophisticated weapons
to defend our borders, reveals the fundamental anguish of humanity
seeking to stand on its own strength and to overcome its fear of
annihilation. Pulled back into the domain of our egotistical little
self, having burned the bridges with the rest of creation and with
our Creator, we feel ourselves always threatened in our acquired
positions. Fragile and ephemeral, they must be defended against
all adversity in the midst of a hostile world. Then a terrible anguish
of not being able to live settles into the soul like a corrosive
substance. Death is at the end of the journey but can already be
seen on the street comer.
Like
the pond which is no longer connected to its source and therefore
goes nowhere, humanity cut off from its Creator, while aspiring
toward him with its whole being, sees this aspiration crumble in
disgust: our life makes no sense, everything is meaningless. More
fearsome than total destruction, whether atomic or biological, is
the total absence of meaning. Money, power, prestige, all the ridiculous
worldliness of a self ever more greedy in its never satisfied aspiration
toward something undefined leads only to the psychiatrist, suicide,
drugs, boredom, and indifference.
The
moment I identify with my little self, I enter into a world of division.
I am fixed and limited; my self has precise boundaries which can
only lead to grim solitude. All modem art, literature, and cinema
are filled with this reality. The more we slip into the pride of
rationality, the more we find ourselves alone and thrown into the
inability to communicate.
The
anguish before death, the absurdity of life, and solitude are the
three aspects of the metaphysical distress of humanity. There is
no worry, no problem or suffering which does not originate there.
And, in the end, the only question we carry within, however unconscious
and repressed it may be, is: "How can I be freed from this despair?"
This question underlies all that we do, from the least to the greatest
act; it is the secret engine of all our initiatives and plunges
us into a sort of mysterious expectation for something else which
should be coming-and yet never shows up! If a liberation exists,
it can manifest itself only at the heart of our triple suffering:
• power
in anguish,
• light
in meaninglessness,
• love
in solitude.
In the
end, original sin is also our original opportunity, allowing us
to rediscover the paradise lost of our depths, our Promised Land
within, if only we will consent to leave our self-imposed exile
and undertake the long journey through the desert of our alienation.
We are at the turning point of history. As in the Middle Ages, we
must once again break through the fog of our downfall and of our
travesty. There will be a new beginning only through the return
to our essence, there where our genesis takes place and where we
can rediscover our true birth.
2
THE
TRUE DIMENSION OF HUMANITY
Prisoners
of our distress and anguish, we forever repress our deeper being.
From this searing suffering, though it remains inexplicable to ordinary
consciousness, can be born an immense yearning for something we
do not know and yet which lives within us.
A certain
agitation, feelings of fear, guilt, and inner emptiness become our
habitual companions. They are there without apparent motive, and
nothing in the world can remedy them: all our security measures
leave that fear untouched; not one of our accumulated riches can
fill the emptiness always widening within; and the honest person
who leads a life without reproach continues to feel a strange guilt.
Through
this yearning, we secretly feel a liberating plenitude beyond all
possession, all power, all knowing that reduce our self to mundane
futilities. We sense the possibility of becoming someone utterly
different through a never ending transformation and through the
existence of meaning beyond all meaning and meaninglessness, beyond
all justices and injustices as understood by our reason. We sense
the existence of a love beyond all particular love, independent
and capable of begetting true independence.
This
yearning for the Infinite which nothing can satisfy is the sign
of Something Else. But this beyond is never a someplace else: it
is in our depths. Yet these depths cannot be reached by our rational
consciousness which measures and defines. We simply feel it, sense
it. It is an intuition of Being which has nothing in common with
the logic of the objectifying self and all that it grips onto. This
intuition becomes stronger and more demanding as it generates a
new consciousness, not in our reason but in our hearts.
We then
begin to take seriously those short, privileged moments of life
which leave us with an unforgettable memory: the day, the hour,
the place where the presence of Being has come through like lightning
and forever marked our memories. Each one of us remembers these
luminous points which are strewn across our existence. Suddenly
and unexpectedly, unrelated to anything, we are transplanted into
a dazzling reality which is absolutely other. This may last only
seconds, yet we know that a dimension which has nothing to do with
space and time has just touched us.
The
occasion is sometimes insignificant, and such an experience often
comes to us when we reach the extreme limit of our reason and face
the walls of our little self. We are drowned in the night of despair.
At that moment, we can be literally seized by the light and find
ourselves projected beyond all anguish, meaninglessness, or solitude!
The
danger is to stop at this experience and say "it was beautiful!"
without having become conscious of what it was all about. Only a
memory will remain-when it actually was a call toward another shore:for
an instant we have been revealed as completely other, who we truly
are, and who we are called to become.
All
our happiness depends on our response to this call. This is the
great difference between the tendency of the East and that of the
West: in the West, we seek to master the external conditions of
life; in the East, we search for the path leading toward inner maturity.
Western culture rests in part on rational knowledge and on a supernatural
revelation which is often only intellectually adhered to. The East,
not knowing such a revelation and having never considered reason
as the valid means of investigating reality and meaning, turned
toward inner experience. Taken seriously, inner experience became
a source of life and a path to wisdom. For the West, far removed
from its source, the East can be the star which will some day awaken
it from its lethargy. For Christians who do not know the essentials
of their faith, the East can be a call to the best of their own
Tradition: a permanent invitation to truths which they have too
often accepted only intellectually or have rejected for the same
reasons.
The
younger generations are aware of all this. It is as though what
was once the privilege of a few is taking hold of great numbers
now. There is talk of a chaotic "rush toward the soul." The foundations
of the God of Reason have cracked: the rise of sects, the great
movement for the development of human potential, and the schools
for the expansion of consciousness, along with groups dealing with
transcendental initiation, the devotees of Krishna, Moon, and many
others. It's enough to take your breath away! Then there is also
Yoga and Zen, and the charismatic renewal. But even if they all
seek something similar, they are far removed from what we are sharing
here.
We ought
not be too optimistic about this phenomenon. The risk is enormous:
putting new wine into old wine sacks! This condemns the wine to
turn bad. Often, the proposed experience actually veils the reality
which the candidate aspires toward with his or her whole being!
And since it is known only as an aspiration, as an inexpressible
yearning, the seeker is not a good judge in the matter. The path
may be doomed to sink into exercises of liberation of self through
the self in a worship of inner dissolution, the seeming benefits
of the relaxation of the tensions of the little self, but ending
only in the no man's land of a superficial self without boundaries.
Or seekers discover in the powers of being a good opportunity for
self-importance. They attribute to themselves powers which come
from a place they know nothing about, and they fall into pride:
they are now at the other extreme of a spiritual experience which
reveals us to ourselves and shows us our relationship to our Creator.
This is enough to keep anyone from being born to a new consciousness
and doom us to wander about indefinitely in the deceit of poor imitations!
There
is, however, something promising occurring in the West, there where
we begin to perceive and to verify an entirely different vision
of humanity. It is not only in the proliferation of mystical groups
that this is manifested, but also in a certain philosophy of life
and the great current of new psychotherapies which are beginning
to seriously rock the foundations of Freudian assumptions. On his
deathbed, C.G. Jung was enthused by his reading of Eastern mystics
and had the feeling that he could have said the same thing they
were saying!
But
the great pioneer and master of this therapy which makes it a wisdom
is Karlfried Graf Durckheim. After more than half a century of research
and experience, of profound assimilation of oriental and western
culture, of long practice with thousands of disciples from around
the world, and of confrontation with his scientific discipline,
he summarized his position at the end of his life in this way:
If
you asked me today to express in one sentence the core of my teaching,
I would answer: taking seriously the double origin of man, celestial
and earthly. The West has forgotten it. In believing that the celestial
was the exclusive realm of faith, and that only the earthly could
be the object of practice and experience, the West has frustrated
man in his spiritual development. Yet, the celestial origin of man
is part of his essential being. Man participates in the depths of
his being with the divine Being and can become conscious of it in
particular experiences. It is the experience of an unconditioned
reality as opposed to the conditioned reality of the existential
self and its world. Man is a citizen of two worlds: the one of existential
reality, limited by time and space, accessible to reason and to
his powers, and the one of essential reality which is beyond time
and space, accessible only to our inner consciousness and inaccessible
to our powers. The destiny of man is to become the one who can witness
to transcendental Reality at the very heart of existence. To achieve
this, we must first learn to take seriously the great experiences
through which, in privileged moments, Being touches us and calls
to us. Ibis is the fundamental meaning of all spiritual experience
as I understand it: to open ourselves to being seized by our essential
being through experiences which manifest it, and to increasingly
develop a way of life which allows us to witness to Being in every
moment.
The
double origin of man is thus opened to experience. It represents
the source, the promise, and the fundamental work of man, whose
basis is awakening to the experience of Being. It seems to me that
the hour has come when the West awakens to an experience of Being
and to a practice of the Way which is not a privilege of the East
alone but can become, on the contrary, the opportunity and the condition
for a truly human religion. (Cited in La Vie Spirituelle, number
592, p. 724).
We find
in these few lines a clear grasp of that which is best in the ancient
Christian Tradition. But it has taken the struggle of a lifetime
to rediscover it under the ruins of the enormous distraction which
has overwhelmed us since the Renaissance! And the battle is far
from being won: will the representatives of most churches accept
a foundation other than their dogmatic systems of thought? Spiritual
experience finds its place there with great difficulty. And for
good reason! The knowledge which it brings and the action to which
it leads are of a radically different nature than objective knowledge
and doctrinal elaborations. It is not that these turn away from
the inner life; on the contrary, they even make it their object
of study. But in doing so they inhibit its advent. In other words:
reason does not have access to things which it debates. To think
about interiority is to move in the realm of opposites and dualism
which the inner experience invites us to leave in order for it to
take place. That is its condition: a reversal of attitudes.
Master
D.T. Suzuki said one day to Durckheim: "Western knowledge looks
toward the outside, Eastern wisdom looks toward the inside. But
if we look within in the way that we look without, we make of the
inside an outside." We objectify, we fix things in a static state,
and that which is alive goes away. This is the tragedy not only
of a certain theology or ecclesiastical practice, but of the whole
of classical psychology and of the structures of education which
are founded upon it.
Durckheim
extended Suzuki's insights and added that it is absolutely vital
to know how to look outside the way we should look inside, making
of the outside an inside!
This
would profoundly change our relation to the world, to things and
to ourselves. Our references would then be based on the most direct
experience. Obviously, we cannot avoid receiving such an experience
through images and formulating it in words, objectifying it in some
way. This is vital if we hope to communicate the experience. That
is not the problem! All religions have sought to formulate in a
coherent way their first experience. What is often forgotten afterward
is that this formulation does not deliver its contents through a
simple lecture or through rational comprehension, but only to the
one who in turn makes it his or her experience. Otherwise, we are
reduced to external approaches, to instruments of analysis or interpretation;
and that which was, at its origin, an invitation to live something
extraordinary, to follow a path of discovery, becomes a quarrel
of schools, a paper chase for diplomas, theoretical arguments, or
a pretext to swell up our "little self." This is hardly a caricature
of what has happened to Christianity!
Without
being reborn on another level of consciousness beyond the rational
self, we do not enter into living contact with this reality whose
quality and significance are radically new, that is to say, of which
we can have no idea based on our own ideas (Ephesians 3:20). That
is why conversion, the great turning around leading to the death
of the ego, is the key to every biblical message as well as to all
other religions. We are each invited into an amazing experience:
"Come and see" (John 1:39). It is the turning point of life which
finally gives us "ears to hear, eyes to see, and a heart to understand"
(Matthew 13: 13-15).
Concretely
speaking, what is this experience which reveals our true dimension?
First of all, it is an experience of the being which we are in our
depths, beyond all image and concept. And, because it is inseparably
linked to it, this is also an experience of absolute Being. But
often Being is neutral to begin with, impersonal, unnameable transcendence,
a burning bush escaping all the usual categories of ordinary consciousness
and invariably answering its first solicitations with: "I Am Who
I Am" (Exodus 3:14). In any case, the inner explosion is overwhelming
and the fire all consuming.
In his
Metaphysical Journal, Gabriel Marcel relates the following: "I
no longer doubt. Miraculous joy this morning. I have for the first
time clearly experienced grace. These words are frightening, but
that is what it is -- and I am submerged. Blessed submersion. But
I don't want to write more. And yet, I feel the need to. This is
truly a birth. Everything is different." Examples like this
are many and varied, but it is,always the same event: the abrupt
breakthrough of Being in our ordinary existence. The phenomenon
can be more or less profound, an ephemeral touch, or an enormous
shaking. Accordingly, Durckheim speaks of a sensation of Being or
an experience of Being. We have said that each of us has some memory
of this kind of sensation, even if it is not spectacular and we
have not attributed much importance to it. Durckheim wrote in his
The Way of Transformation:
We
suddenly feel ourselves in a strange arnbiance. We are entirely
present, completely there, and yet not focused on anything in particular.
We feel ourselves in a very peculiar way, without harshness, harmonious
within ourselves, and very open. Because of this openness, a profound
fullness emerges. We are both absent and present, overflowing with
life. We rest within ourselves and we discover an inner affinity
with everything that surrounds us. We are united to everything,
yet detached from everything. We feel ourselves incredibly guided
and yet free from all obligation; poor in this world but covered
with riches and inner power.
This
is a participation in Being. The certainty that I am fully myself
and that "I Am the One Who Is" arises from the same creative act
in this point where the two join together.But this sensation of
Being is often only a preparation, the messenger of the experience
of Being which is overwhelming and liberating in another way. When
our human distress reaches an impossible paradox, and our way of
living becomes an attitude of surrender, we then open ourselves
to an invasion from beyond.
This
has often been seen in the depths of despair, in the terrifying
anguish of death or annihilation. There again the experiences are
many: situations where death is close, bombings or wars, serious
illness, accidents. Fear is at its height, death is inevitable,
the last defenses of the little self are about to crumble. If at
that precise moment, we consent to lose our acquired positions and
accept the unacceptable, we are suddenly invaded by a prodigious
peace, freed from all fear and absolute ly unassailable by death,
however near it may be. For this living "thing" has taken hold of
us, an indescribable Power and Fullness which have nothing to do
with death; we find our selves in an entirely different dimension.
We are another person.
The
same experience is even better known among those who find themselves
at the extreme limits of an absurd situa tion, plunged into the
meaninglessness of life, when no remedy is possible. Situations
of terrible injustices, inhuman treat ment, senseless conditions
of life-times when resignation and rebellion would be dead ends.
Being able to accept the unacceptable, that is to say, consenting
to leave behind ordinary consciousness, is to be suddenly transfigured
by a Light which transcends absurdity or meaninglessness. It is
a deeper meaning, beyond all meaning and meaninglessness, an in
conceivable inner order.
Other
distresses which can provoke this experience of Being occur when
we are thrown into complete solitude: the loss of someone very close
to us, being excluded from a community, or total isolation. Let
this reality penetrate you and say "yes" to the impossible pain,
if only for a few seconds. This can introduce you to a Love beyond
all limits of time and place. We then feel ourselves vitalized from
within, surrounded at the heart of solitude, deeply connected to
others, closer to them than ever before.
Every
time this dimension seizes us, it reveals its trinitarian character.
Everyone knows that the richest man in the world is also the saddest!
This comes from having lost his roots. The person who recognizes
the essence of this agony discovers the ultimate secret of all his
desires: to live fully, realizing his personhood and rediscovering
unity. This is why we long for Being when we are cut off from it.
Whether we are conscious of this or not, always and everywhere we
discover ourselves and the world under this triple aspect. All reality,
all that lives, is animated, penetrated, centered in the Trinity
of Being, and nothing either in humanity or in the universe is outside
of this key to everything:
- The
Source which gives Life: that which lives does not live through
itself, but receives Power and Fullness from Being which wants to
give itself and manifest itself in existence. Closed off from this
creative source, we necessarily fall into agony and insecurity,
the fear of death.
- The
Word which gives Form: that which lives realizes itself in its particular
form and becomes itself. It is the meaning of life, the Light of
Being which seeks to manifest itself in a different image through
every creature. The refusal to do so leads to the fall into meaninglessness.
- The
Breath which gives Harmony and Movement: it leads all that lives
beyond and through all differentiation toward the Totality and Unity
of Being in which all participate. This energy re-creates unity
within us and within all that surrounds us, taking us out of solitude
and division. We are then transfigured.
This
experience of the Trinity of Being is a "leap into a new kind of
consciousness, a rebirth in the roots of man," according to Durckheim.
The old self dies; a new being which has discovered its true center
appears. Opposites are abolished, dualism is overcome, subject-object
converge. This is the epiphany of Life so hoped for and awaited
in the concrete existence of each one of us, as Christ revealed
and promised it: creative Force of the Father, Light of the Son,
vivifying Energy of the Spirit. In coming to heal the wounds of
humanity, God reveals a triple face. Desperate humanity longs for
the Divine Trinity -- to such an extent that if one of the three
Presences were to vanish, life would no longer be possible.
Since
these statements completely escape the control of reason, we can
question the credibility of such experiences. Are they not illusions
or projections of a completely subjective sentimentalism? What are
the criteria which allow us to rec ognize that this is truly an
experience of another dimension, an experience of Being? The old
spiritual traditions have discerned many, the most important being
the birth of a certain taste, the radiance of persons who come out
of an experience of Being, especially their transformation, not
forgetting the intervention at that very moment of the Demon, the
Adversary of life and of all spiritual progress.
We first
experience a particular taste which occurs when we come in contact
with people and things, a kind of intuition of the numinous diffused
everywhere. The numinous is a superior quality which indicates to
us the presence of another re ality, completely different from the
one that falls immediately under our senses, a quality which we
can perceive in all that surrounds us, especially in moments when
the phrase "it's beautiful!" no longer suffices to express what
we feel. It is not simply a qualitative or superlative word. Teilhard
de Chardin has written wonderful pages on this diaphany of Being
in the world:
I
had truly acquired a new sense, the sense of a new quality or dimension.
Deeper still: a transformation had occurred within me in the very
perception of being. Being had now become in some way tangible,
tasty. Coming through all the forms which he puts on, being itself
began to attract and intoxicate me. A Universal Smile coming from
the heart of things ... the first shiver perceived from the world
animated by the Incarnation ... incandescent inward layers within
each life. (The Divine Milieu)
At such
times, we always experience fullness and unity to the extent that
our deeper consciousness is awakened. These are powerful experiences,
sometimes causing overwhelming fascination, sometimes simple sparks
of wonder. Those who live with the Psalms are filled with this mysterious
Presence everywhere perceptible and make of it their nourishment.
For them, the whole of creation becomes a place of communion with
God, for there is nothing which is not the expression of God's glory
and the receptacle of God's Breath (Psalm 104).
The
second criterion, that of exceptional radiance of the one who is
opened to Being, is just as astonishing. It has nothing in common
with the natural light which emanates from our ordinary moods and
our mundane joys. Nor is it the false radiance which comes from
a strong personality where the self leaves no room for Being. But
rather it is a profound transparence which lets appear a Force of
another order and gives rise to an atmosphere of a particular character,
undefinable, manifesting the presence of Life in all its freshness
and purity. Since this is not a matter of a localized optical phenomenon,
the objectifying consciousness cannot grasp it. Only the one who
is himself transparent to Being can be touched by it. "He who participates
with the divine energy," says Gregory Palamas, "becomes himself,
in some way, the Light; he is united to the light and with the Light."
This is infinitely more than a simple criterion of verification.
The reality of the Light, known to all religions, is so inherent
in all Orthodox theology and liturgy that they are impossible without
it.
This
leads us to the third criterion, which is transformation: the Light
is nothing else than the visible character of God who communicates
himself to us in order to lead us to our own deification. "You will
be as gods," say the Holy Scriptures. Transformation is the best
argument in witnessing to the truth of the experience of this other
dimension of humanity. We cannot accuse someone of sentimental subjectivism
or of illusion when he or she has been completely changed through
the experience of Being and now lives a radically new life, profoundly
liberated from obsession with death, the meaninglessness of life,
and solitude.
But
this transcendent reality is not just a liberation from our despair.
It is also a permanent questioning of all our acquired positions
and of all our fixations, a complete reversal of our values, an
abolition of all false securities, and a reconsideration of our
way of life. A new dimension must appear which nothing can wall
up and which has nothing to do with ordinary consciousness. It is
not even the summit of this consciousness, but rather another consciousness
altogether: a consciousness-vision which does not divide or oppose,
but which ties everything together in a single bundle.
This
unity of vision is the unity of Being, and through that the conquest
of time and space. The infinite is then seen in the finite of things
and all eternity in the passing second. Each instant is an absolute,
a complete whole, a beatitude. The opposite is the constant projection
into the future or pull toward the past of a mind which is never
present, tossed about by hopes and regrets. It is the same for space:
everything is a totality for this new consciousness; engendered
by the Absolute, it discovers the Absolute everywhere and is in
turn recognized by this inexpressible Reality. This is wonder. At
the center of the least object, infinite immensity which contains
everything is unveiled.
3
MEDITATION:
A PRIVILEGED PATH
It is
in this context of life and death that we must trace a path. We
are at the crossroads. And the decision for the journey can come
only from persons or communities who have become aware of the depths
of their being and are present to the adventure of the twentieth
century. Both must be held together, for this is not the time to
run away in search of mystical comforts. The inner life is not a
decadent complacency of the self or "bourgeois" luxury. We must
look directly in the face of the realities of our time!
But
how is this possible? Many believe that it is already too late to
humanize the inhuman forces at work among us. In the light of historical
facts as well as of our widespread neurosis, there is indeed no
convincing reason to believe in the advent of a sudden mental mutation
which would allow us to bring about an entirely different future.
There are some who hope that biological progress will soon synthesize
a hormone or an enzyme which will be able to heal our paranoid dispositions.
Will
the salvation of humanity come out of laboratories? Will it appear
on the shelves of pharmacies and be picked out by consumers? The
day may not be far off when we will add the elixir of a mental stabilizer
to drinking water so as to lower criminal behavior, to enhance the
coordination of neurological circuits, to lessen conflict, and to
normalize things.
But
this would be criminal in itself, transmuting humans into passive
robots. It would be naive to hope that drugs could regenerate the
spirit, introducing something that was not already there. A revolution
of an entirely different order is needed because humanity is of
a different order, and if we now face our greatest threat, we will
be able to conquer it only by acts which are equally without precedence.
Before such an extraordinarily new danger we need to find the source
of the original and true creative power.
Today,
we must rediscover ourselves in all our dimensions. Humanity's most
heroic adventure is not the exploration of our external universe,
however infinite it may be, but the jour ney toward our true nature.
Infinity is found within us. Only from there will the world be re-created,
for that is its origin: the inner force of humanity!
To survive,
humanity needs a spiritual revolution. All the greats of our century
converge around this point, believers and unbelievers alike. Nietzsche's
Zarathustra was not the product. of a degenerate imagination but
the first to observe that humanity must rise above itself. Einstein
insisted on the transformation of human life in its totality, the
necessity for conversion. Jaspers, another agnostic, went even further
and did not hesitate to state that everything comes from the individual
and depends on him. We have no other power than to draw from the
liberty which rests in our depths. To dare to be an individual is
to become transfigured in our relationship with our inner freedom,
or, for believers, in our relationship with God. The emphasis here
is not on the isolation of the self but on the intensity, the passionate
interest of the self's relationship with God (or its being, its
freedom), and through God, with others and the world.
This
requires a permanent watchfulness. The place of this accomplishment
is meditation, the kind which we will be describing here, exposing
us to both the incessant movement of transformation within and genuine
encounter with the outer world. This dialectic must be held together,
otherwise we fall into a kind of suffocation of the self by the
self or into a destructive rationalism. We might call it "active
wisdom," liberating the extraordinary potential of our spiritual
forces and finally letting surface all the happiness which inhabits
us already.
This
is what meditation aims at: creating a living person who sees God.
The human being's masterwork is himself or herself. The word meditation
does not mean here a reflection on a theme or on some rational thought
process. Meditation is understood here as a path of transformation.
It is a maturation of the entire person: in our relationship to
ourselves; in our relationship to others and to the world; in our
relationship to God; in the transfiguration within us of Absolute
Being.
We therefore
take the word meditation in its literal sense, meditari (itari
in medio), which means being led toward the center. The center
is not something toward which we concentrate, but something which
concentrates us, uniting us from within, toward the interior. This
center is essential Being, our transcendent kernel which is felt
as a state in which the opposition of subject-object is dissolved.
Such a state of relaxation is followed by the sensation of the birth
of a new form. This is how essential Being itself makes its entry
into our consciousness and is felt there as the vital center of
a new awareness of the world. We feel as though we are newly born.
Karlfried Durckheirn. tells us that "this contact with Being begins
with an almost unconscious yearning of the heart and must be followed
ceaselessly, until we reach the fundamental experience of the explosion
of self and the realization of Being, which transforms everything."
II
ON
THE WAY TOWARD THE WAY:
HOW
TO MEDITATE
SITTING
IN MEDITATION
Since
the secret of Self and God is "absolutely unlike any idea we may
have created" (Berdiaev), all platonic meditation is doomed to failure.
Many have "meditated" their entire lives, as much as an hour a day,
and yet they find themselves in their old age full of bitterness.
"They are spiritually sick. Far from being empty themselves, they
are full; they become angry as soon as their self-centered interests
are touched or threatened. They seek vengeance for the wrong that
has been done to them because they are burdened with an I which
can be injured" (Merton). That kind of meditation or prayer is a
narcissism which does not know itself, a perversion of the spirit,
or simple cerebral sensuality comforting the old man in his unconscious
refusal of the Gospel. This is not the Path of transformation.
Meditation
can only be an exercise of the whole person, in which nothing escapes
the call to conversion, not even the least cell of the body. Everything
must work toward the transparence to Being and prepare itself to
die so that it may be transfigured by It. Here, extremes touch and
interpenetrate each other--the person is one. To join with our extreme
interiority, at the very edge of the mysterious source of life in
order to receive it, is not an abandonment of the exterior world
but its integration. It is here that everything begins, through
the body that I am. The body is not an object, but our way of being
present: in this sense, I am my body because it is my expression
in the world, my capacity to achieve the original unity in which
opposites are melted down so that we may reach beyond all soul-body
duality in order to live in a new dimension. Therefore, everything
in our life takes root in our corporal experience. All that expresses
balance, movement and creativity, especially when it is a matter
of the advent of Life itself, all things which are the condition
of being human respect the laws written in the flesh.
In this
sense, it is striking that the Bible does not even have a word to
describe the body as separated from the rest! Unity is such that
there is no modification of the body without a modification of the
spirit and vice versa as saint Basil said so strongly in the fourth
century. The three essential functions which allow the body the
realization of unity are: right attitude, appropriate tension, and
breathing. It is through these that we enter into meditation. This
is when there exists the possibility of transparence. At the dawn
of human wisdom, we find Patanjali and the Buddha sitting in lotus
position. It has been said that this way of sitting is humanity's
most inspired discovery. It allows people of all times and of all
traditions to realize that for which they were born.
Despite
appearances, there is nothing oriental about it. It is so appropriate
to universal humanity that as soon as the little rational self is
no longer at the center, people will want to sit this way. This
explains why the mentally retarded, for instance, spontaneously
take this position and that western mystics appropriate it without
having learned it. On the other hand, to the intellectual person,
it always offers the opportunity for an absolutely privileged path.
This way of sitting allows a total immobility for a length of time,
an utter letting go, and the experience of a rebirth from within
the vital center. However, the exterior form of the lotus position
is only an indication. Right sitting, or the fundamental posture,
is not at all linked to the rigor of that position!
The
most important factor is that the backbone be straight, and the
knees lower than the pelvic region. With that in mind, one can sit
in many different ways which are as traditional as the lotus position.
"Each will choose that which will be most appropriate for him,"
said Theophan the Recluse. He added that "the attention of the soul
depends also on a suitable position of the body."
THE
LOTUS:
Sit
on a cushion or a folded blanket, legs stretched out before you.
Take the right foot and place it, with the soul of the foot facing
upward, on the left thigh, then do the same with the left foot.
Both knees should touch the floor.
THE
HALF-LOTUS:
As with
the lotus, except that only one of the feet is placed on the opposite
thigh while the other rests on the floor in front of it.
THE
CUP:
Here
the legs are not crossed but only folded, one foot in front of the
other, soles facing upward. Be sure the cushion is the right height,
or it will be hard to keep the legs on the floor and the backbone
straight.
TRADITIONAL
POSTURE:
Also
known as the carmelite posture or the tailor's position. Place the
knees on a blanket, the tips of the toes slightly covering each
other, then sit in the hollow of the heels. The knees can be together
or spread out. Many beginners use a cushion in this posture which
they slip between the heels and the buttocks. This makes the position
less painful. You can also use a small stool, or a wooden cube to
sit on.
ON A
CHAIR:
For
those who find it hard to use one of the above postures, it is certainly
possible to meditate on a chair. Do not lean back, but sit on the
front edge, legs perpendicular to the floor, the feet parallel,
soles firmly placed flat, or cross the ankles, with the knees always
lower than the pelvis, otherwise the vital center is not freed up.
Every
way of sitting requires a time of apprenticeship at the beginning.
Our body, deformed by false attitudes which our sick spirit enforces
upon it, will suffer in the first few months. A whole reconditioning
must take place. The joints will hurt, but this suffering must not
be useless. Accepted and felt from within, it will become the junction
of the body and the soul and take its place on the Way to the unity
we seek. Soon this effort to sit in meditation will become more
agreeable, will easily last longer, and will be taken without effort.
It will
have become second nature, or rather an opportunity for our true
nature to express itself fully! As soon as we are seated, we will
feel our whole being relax, and a sensation of well-being set in.
To the absolute immobility of the body will quickly correspond a
surprising calm of the spirit and of the emotions. It becomes a
true recollection in the deepest sense of the word. And eventually,
this posture will reveal itself not only as that which is most restful,
but as that which is most regenerative: open to the mysterious forces
of Being, we will leave our meditation with a new vitality.
THE
HANDS
The
way of holding one's hands is very important. They are in a way
the prolongation of our consciousness. We can place them in different
ways, of course, but you will notice, confirming thousands of years
of experience, to what extent inner attention is increased when
the fingers of the left hand rest on the fingers of the right hand,
or vice versa if you are left handed. The thumbs, placed horizontally,
lightly touch each other and form with the fingers a sphere, the
symbol of the celestial world; the forearms rest on the top of the
thighs, the sides of the hands in contact with the abdomen. It is
most important that the shoulders fall normally in perfect relaxation,
the elbows supple. The whole creates a large cup, symbol of the
inner cup, ready to receive that which must die and give birth to
new forms of being. The magnetic field of this microcosm which is
our body is thus closed by the hands and the feet: the energy can
then circulate freely.
THE
EYES
They
are to remain, if possible, partly closed during meditation. This
will seem difficult for those who are in the habit of closing them,
but one can get use to this quickly. The masters say that there
is practically no progress when we meditate with our eyes closed.
Moreover, sleep can often take over, along with distractions of
all kinds and daydreaming. Maintaining contact with the exterior
world helps to stabililize the body. So, with your eyes half open,
eyelids relaxed, a neutral look placed on a point approximately
a yard ahead, we fix our gaze on nothing, letting our attention
go inward.
THE
BACKBONE
This
is the most essential aspect of sitting in meditation. To sit up
straight usually means for most of us sticking out the chest and
holding in the stomach because we have lost our center of gravity
and live on the surface of ourselves. This posture is taught in
all the armies of the world and those other barracks we call schools.
For violence is only possible (whether in scholastic competition
or under gunfire) when we are expulsed from our Self toward the
small and frightened self, where eliminating the other becomes the
law of survival.
We must
therefore rediscover the right posture with our center of gravity
in the stomach. The simplest way, once seated, with our hands properly
placed, is to lean forward, then reconstruct the vertical position
from its base, beginning at the level of the coccyx, rising one
vertebrae at a time. Coming to the head, we then pull the spinal
column up and let it sit on itself, vertebrae on vertebrae, without
sinking toward the bottom or becoming rigid at the top. The spinal
cord is straight but supple.
THE
NECK
The
neck is a crucial area. If it leans forward or backward too much,
it breaks the continuity of the vertical position and inhibits the
descent into the self. In order to keep it in line with the spinal
cord, you simply need to bring in the chin a little and not lose
the contact between the top and back of the head and the ceiling
or sky. Rooted in the sky, rooted in the earth, such is our constitution
as human being.
THE
LOWER STOMACH
It is
this rooting in the earth which we must now work with. The vertical
position rests on a foundation. As long as it is not solid, the
rest is very fragile. Taking root in the earth depends entirely
on a letting go at the top: we must first release and relax in depth
in the neck and shoulders at the beginning of each expiration. This
letting go of oneself is automatically followed by a great movement
of confidence toward the lower: at the end of the expiration, we
are literally sitting in our belly, which in its turn expands, relaxes,
and roots itself deeper and deeper.
If the
expiration is gently but firmly directed toward the lower parts,
without any effort, the lower stomach will easily free itself. In
prolonging the expiration at the end of its normal course, the abdominal
inner wall is lightly tensed, which allows us to feel a force in
the entire pelvic region. This stability of the whole is now unshakeable,
in its center of gravity, and the whole person can now relax from
top to bottom.
A LIVING
SPACE
The
proper vertical position is not rigid like a broom handle, but supple
in a way which allows the spinal cord to gravitate around a fine
point from which life arises. There is a simple way to find it which
consists in moving back and forth several times with the whole of
the spinal cord, in rhythm with our breathing. The movement diminishes
progressively and stops of its own in a space of several millimeters
without ever losing either its vertical position nor the contact
of the head with the sky. In this little space, this mysterious
point, we feel a true well-being, a life which invades the whole
body from its center. If we are too far forward or backward, rigid
at the top or slumped toward the bottom, everything is dead, as
each person will quickly discover.
TRANSPARENT
TO THE TRANSCENDENT
To believe
that all this puts too much importance on the physical would be
to hold to a deadly dualism of body and soul. It is true that centuries
of spiritual ideologies and theological concepts have not helped
us to live in the humility of our body! Yet it is through the body
that I am: my body is myself, my way of being in the world. Even
in the least gesture I can perceive something of my interiority,
just as, inversely, any gesture, attitude or action has a profound
influence on my inner universe and can become an occasion to shape
me on the Way.
The
body therefore always expresses either a right way of being there,
or a false way of being there. It is false when it inhibits, by
all the tensions in the upper part of the body, the contact with
Being and the possibility for Its manifestation; it is right when
it allows a letting go of the dominating self and an openness to
the fullness of Being. If the exercise of the right attitude is
properly followed, it leads to a "whole evolution of the person
which signifies much more than a new way of holding oneself," writes
Durckheim. "It is not a matter of a new physical attitude, but of
a profound transformation of the person. Anchoring oneself little
by little in a deeper foundation brings about a fundamental change.
It expresses itself in a new way of seeing and accepting the world,
in bearing suffering, in a new way of living...The Hara, the belly,
opens an access to Being.
We are
conformed to our essential being and fulfill it." This is an attitude
of transparence before the transcendent, the awakening of a new
consciousness which seeks to maintain this contact continually through
the activities of daily life. We can take on the habit of living
from this deeper center, whatever the circumstances, and it eventually
becomes intolerable to give ourselves over again to the palpitations
of the little surface self.
THE
RIGHT TENSION
We only
enter into the right attitude through the proper tension of the
whole person through the body which we are. Right tension means
a harmonious relationship between tension and relaxation. This is
where we can best observe the difference between the body which
we are and the body which we have. There is a great gulf between
saying "I have tension in my arm" and "I am tensed in my arm." In
the first case, I relax the muscle and the feeling is solved by
simple physical therapy; in the second case, I relax as a person
and I then open within myself a new dimension which completely escapes
the domination of the willfull self. These are two different visions
of what it means to be human and everything changes radically according
to which one we are inspired by. Consider the enormous revisions
in medicine and education under these new relationships!
THE
TENSIONS OF THE BODY
A tension
in one part of the body is always a blockage on the inner Way, for
it reveals a personality distortion, a contraction of the self on
acquired positions or a subconscious desire to affirm ourselves
against our fears and insecurities. These kinds of tensions are
innumerable, as varied as the circumstances of life and the people
we come upon. A trifle can throw some people into the most tenacious
contractions: obsession, unappeased desire, resentment, irritation...Everyone
takes their own particular poison. But whatever the tension, even
the slightest one, it affects the entire person and inhibits transformation.
"It matters little," says John of the Cross,"if it is a thread of
silk or a heavy cord which holds the bird's leg, since it makes
its flight impossible..."
Most
of the time, it is an ensemble of tensions, more or less latent,
sometimes very old, but constantly maintained, which forms the enclosure
of a self forever preoccupied, centered in the top part of the body,
far from any liberating confidence and begetting an utterly petrified
existence. To relax a part of the body always means to let go of
everything which is the expression of a person centered only on
the egocentric self, and results in an increasing release from captivity
as the contact with one's essential being is rediscovered. This
contact is a slow but incessant maturation which is never fully
completed. Inasmuch as I have learned to let go of all the tensions
and fixations within, I witness the birth of a new form which must
immediately be protected from the temptation of a new hardening
through a letting go forever renewed.
That
is how I enter into the wheel of metamorphosis where this maturation
is characterized by a permanent transformation of forms which die
and are reborn in the great movement of life, along the rhythm of
the breath. If we live this process consciously, we are in this
vivifying harmony of tension-relaxation which is the secret dynamism
of all existence, carrying it to its ultimate realization through
the manifestation of Being in all our attitudes.
Nothing
will then stop us on the Way and each moment which presents itself
is for us THE best occasion for progress. Life only takes on meaning
in and through this continual maturing. Right attitude, proper tension
and breathing form a whole, interpenetrating each other in a growing
fusion which engages the whole person on another level. Though they
must be treated here separately, it must be understood that relaxation,
as with these other actions, is not an exercise of the body which
would do some good for the spirit but an entirely other requirement;
only experience will confirm this.
THE
EXERCISE OF RELAXATION
The
techniques of relaxation are many. A fundamental element among all
of them is FEELING. To receive a sensation in its pure state, without
interpretation, creates an immediate disconnection in the nerve
centers, silencing the soul and the body. Psychosomatic research
has obtained surprising results, healing neurosis of all kinds and
even some paralysis. This is the scientific resurgence of the ancient
but formidable intuitions of the Desert Fathers who came through
the silence of body and soul to that "inviolable sovereign liberty"
(John Cassian).
What
does this mean for us? Once in sitting position, perfectly Still,
become conscious of your breathing for a few moments. Breathe slowly
and deeply. Then go through the whole body, from head to toe, by
feeling from within one part then another and relax each place as
you breathe out. This may seem difficult at first since the ability
to feel in this way is completely atrophied in some people. But
the capacity for interior perception refines itself very quickly
and deepens at every session. Even if we feel nothing right away,
the process of relaxation brings benefits from the very first attempt.
This does not mean jumping quickly from one part of the body to
another, but going to each part, from its surface to its depths,
from exterior toward interior, and remaining there...feeling...and
tasting the fullness of the sensation.
We begin
with the head. I feel my scalp like a hood...the temples...the ears...the
forehead...Simply feeling...Releasing the eyebrows...giving back
to the forehead its serenity...its luminosity. In breathing out,
feel the nose...the eyes...One can feel in a certain way the relaxation
which expiration brings to the eyes. Feel your cheeks from within...Relax
all the many little muscles in the contour of your lips...Relax
the jaws. Keep the lips together. The result of this relaxation
of the forehead, eyes and jaws is an almost invisible smile. It
is a smile that we see on the face of saints and sages, and also
on the face of the dead for they have finally completely let go.
This interior smile must not leave during the whole meditation.
Good relaxation of the tongue also affects the whole organism. Be
sure that it is not tensed against the palate. Feel your tongue...Relax
the throat, for it is often knotted up by anxiety or simply because
we never cease speaking to ourselves. Let go!
Upon
expiration, go to the back of the neck, that area so important for
our interior development. It is there that the enormous tensions
of our arrogant self go to crystallize, along with the tensions
of the self which continually seeks to protect itself. You can feel
this like a board between the shoulders or through a stiff neck
as the Bible calls it. Let go of yourself from that false protection,
open all that part of the top of the backbone right between the
shoulders. Feel the relaxation... Then relax the shoulders by trying
to feel them deeply from within, in all their length and breadth.
This does not mean pushing them down mechanically, but simply letting
go of yourself in the shoulder. Now feel the weight of the arms
slide gently toward the elbows right into the forearms and the hands.
Repeat the movement several times. Feel your arms getting heavier
and heavier, warmer and warmer as they relax completely. Let go
of yourself in the hands, inside the hands...
Afterwards,
feel the two arms at the same time, from the neck to the hands like
a big circle, always heavier and more relaxed with each expiration...
Then, without ever sinking down, relax your back. On every expiration,
feel the whole back dialate, relaxing on both sides of the spinal
cord...Do the same in the chest. Feel it breathe...It is as if it
opened in the center and everything expands and relaxes more and
more. Feel it... Now feel the circumference of the belly area. Let
it expand, becoming larger and larger, like the foundations of a
pyramid. Let go of the lower stomach region...It is heavy, as though
filled with lead, expanding... Feel the sitting position, the muscles
of the buttocks...Then, as with the arms, feel the weight of the
legs slide slowly toward the knees, through the calves, to the very
ends of the feet...Feel your legs becoming heavier and heavier,
warmer and warmer, relaxed...Repeat this movement several times,
as needed. You can focus on each leg individually, as with each
arm. This might be easier for beginners.
Some
practitioners relax only the right arm and this relaxation, when
it is well done and done completely, acts by osmosis on the rest
of the body, revealing our interior unity. Once you have gone through
your body, feel it all at once, from within. Relax completely as
you breathe out, always in perfect immobility and with good posture.
This exercise of relaxation can be done systematically at the beginning
of each meditation. With the beginner, this will take perhaps fifteen
or twenty minutes; but as you progress, it will only require a few
moments. You need to begin with this effort, if you can, for our
attention is in direct proportion to relaxation and it is this alone
which allows the focus of our entire being. We now come to the doorway
of meditation. The ways of approach are many. One must seek, experiment,
and eventually everyone find his or her path, guided by their own
inner force.
THE
SENSATION OF THE DIVINE
Once
we have attained a certain depth and well-being, the exercise of
relaxation can become meditation. It must not be reduced to a simple
technique. As experience will show, it leads nowhere to consider
the different parts of one's body from the exterior as objects and
seek to relax them! We must develop the habit of entering into our
body with all our consciousness, remain in the heaviness of our
members a long time without resistance; there, we must taste the
body that we are, perceive with all our being the profound change
which slowly enters into our way of being present: the absence of
boundaries, the exclusion of the dominating self, the unusual warmth
of the body, the feeling of a mysterious Force which carries us
and sustains us, the impression of total surrender. I no longer
belong to myself and yet I am more myself than ever, intensely recollected
in myself and yet connected to the whole universe...
This
is an openness of our entire being to that which transcends it infinitely,
as though we had responded to the secret but permanent invitation
of the breath of the Spirit in the depths of our heart: "Ephatha,
be opened" (Mark 7:34). Indeed, the depth of each sensation is a
recreation of oneself, a veritable march toward liberty, that is,
the awakening of the person beneath the ashes of the little self.
Far from a simple muscular release, relaxation opens the doors of
the inner mystery and offers the body as a place of covenant with
God. "Behold, I stand at the door and knock; if any one hears my
voice and opens the door, I will come in to him and eat with him,
and he with me" (Rev 3:20)...."Offer your bodies to God...The body
is meant for the Lord...Do you not know that you are a temple of
God?" (Rom 12:1; 1Cor 6:13).
But,
if it is true that our body is the sanctuary of the divine Presence,
we can say with saint Gregory of Palamas that we are "flesh of His
Flesh and bones of His bones..." God finally ceases to be "a ghost"
for us, for we can now "touch him" (Luke 24:39)! We do not encounter
him in abstractions or words: "Do not heap up empty phrases" says
the Christ (Mtt 6:7), "Touch me!" (Luke 24:39). If he has in fact
come out of the insurmountable Abyss which "no eye has seen, nor
ear heard," it is precisely in order to become flesh and to assimilate
himself to us so that we might "see His Majesty with our own eyes"
(2Peter 1:16), "hear him with our own ears" (Mtt 13:9 and 16), "touch
him with our hands" (1John 1:1), feel him with our whole being and
let ourselves be seized by Him.
This
meditation through feeling goes from the exterior toward the interior,
from our surface toward our depths. The sensation is ephemeral:
it appears and disappears, lasts only a fraction of a second, but
like the wave is linked to the immense depths of the entire ocean.
So too is the sensation linked to the infinite of our inner consciousness
and, if we remain within it, leads us into the sensation of the
Divine...the feeling of an ineffable Presence, a contact with Mystery
which enters into the very least of our cells. As fire penetrates
iron, the latter keeps its substance but becomes and realizes the
fire which inhabits it and literally trans-figures it. This marvelous
parable used for the first time by saint Macarius the Elder resonates
through the Christian tradition, from East to West. Today as yesterday,
Christ invites us to climb the holy Mountain and enter with him
into the divine fire. Meditation concretely opens the path.
3
MEDITATION:
A PRIVILEGED PATH
It is
in this context of life and death that we must trace a path. We
are at the crossroads. And the decision for the journey can come
only from persons or communities who have become aware of the depths
of their being and are present to the adventure of the twentieth
century. Both must be held together, for this is not the time to
run away in search of mystical comforts. The inner life is not a
decadent complacency of the self or "bourgeois" luxury. We must
look directly in the face of the realities of our time!
But
how is this possible? Many believe that it is already too late to
humanize the inhuman forces at work among us. In the light of historical
facts as well as of our widespread neurosis, there is indeed no
convincing reason to believe in the advent of a sudden mental mutation
which would allow us to bring about an entirely different future.
There are some who hope that biological progress will soon synthesize
a hormone or an enzyme which will be able to heal our paranoid dispositions.
Will
the salvation of humanity come out of laboratories? Will it appear
on the shelves of pharmacies and be picked out by consumers? The
day may not be far off when we will add the elixir of a mental stabilizer
to drinking water so as to lower criminal behavior, to enhance the
coordination of neurological circuits, to lessen conflict, and to
normalize things.
But
this would be criminal in itself, transmuting humans into passive
robots. It would be naive to hope that drugs could regenerate the
spirit, introducing something that was not already there. A revolution
of an entirely different order is needed because humanity is of
a different order, and if we now face our greatest threat, we will
be able to conquer it only by acts which are equally without precedence.
Before such an extraordinarily new danger we need to find the source
of the original and true creative power.
Today,
we must rediscover ourselves in all our dimensions. Humanity's most
heroic adventure is not the exploration of our external universe,
however infinite it may be, but the jour ney toward our true nature.
Infinity is found within us. Only from there will the world be re-created,
for that is its origin: the inner force of humanity!
To survive,
humanity needs a spiritual revolution. All the greats of our century
converge around this point, believers and unbelievers alike. Nietzsche's
Zarathustra was not the product. of a degenerate imagination but
the first to observe that humanity must rise above itself. Einstein
insisted on the transformation of human life in its totality, the
necessity for conversion. Jaspers, another agnostic, went even further
and did not hesitate to state that everything comes from the individual
and depends on him. We have no other power than to draw from the
liberty which rests in our depths. To dare to be an individual is
to become transfigured in our relationship with our inner freedom,
or, for believers, in our relationship with God. The emphasis here
is not on the isolation of the self but on the intensity, the passionate
interest of the self's relationship with God (or its being, its
freedom), and through God, with others and the world.
This
requires a permanent watchfulness. The place of this accomplishment
is meditation, the kind which we will be describing here, exposing
us to both the incessant movement of transformation within and genuine
encounter with the outer world. This dialectic must be held together,
otherwise we fall into a kind of suffocation of the self by the
self or into a destructive rationalism. We might call it "active
wisdom," liberating the extraordinary potential of our spiritual
forces and finally letting surface all the happiness which inhabits
us already.
This
is what meditation aims at: creating a living person who sees God.
The human being's masterwork is himself or herself. The word meditation
does not mean here a reflection on a theme or on some rational thought
process. Meditation is understood here as a path of transformation.
It is a maturation of the entire person: in our relationship to
ourselves; in our relationship to others and to the world; in our
relationship to God; in the transfiguration within us of Absolute
Being.
We therefore
take the word meditation in its literal sense, meditari (itari
in medio), which means being led toward the center. The center
is not something toward which we concentrate, but something which
concentrates us, uniting us from within, toward the interior. This
center is essential Being, our transcendent kernel which is felt
as a state in which the opposition of subject-object is dissolved.
Such a state of relaxation is followed by the sensation of the birth
of a new form. This is how essential Being itself makes its entry
into our consciousness and is felt there as the vital center of
a new awareness of the world. We feel as though w